Fake payment emails: checks before you sell
A payment email can look convincing. Check the order in the app before dispatching, handing over an item or entering account details.
What to do
- Close the email. Do not tap its links or call a number in it.
- Open PayPal or Wise yourself and look for the payment, including a pending one.
- Send or hand over the item only when the paid order is in the app you opened yourself.
- 01Read the request, not just the logo
- 02A fake PayPal email on Gumtree or Facebook Marketplace
- 03Open the order independently
- 04If you already followed a link
- 05Keep a record for review
Read the request, not just the logo
Treat a request to pay money to receive a payment, refund an overpayment separately, or share a login code as a reason to stop. The sender name and logo do not prove who sent it.
A fake PayPal email on Gumtree or Facebook Marketplace
A message that says the money is already waiting is not proof of payment. Use the same checks if you are selling on Facebook Marketplace, or if the email uses a Wise logo and says you have been paid.
Do not dispatch or hand the item over because of the email. Open PayPal or Wise yourself, in its app or by typing the address. Ignore any link, phone number or request for a tracking number in the message. Read marketplace scams, a missing parcel and how you get paid.
PayPal’s UK help page says a spoofed email claiming you have received a payment is used to get a seller to ship an item for free. Log in to PayPal and check your activity before you ship. PayPal says it does not ask for a tracking number by email, and a payment you received shows in your PayPal activity. Source
PayPal’s UK phishing guide says it does not ask for sensitive information in an email. Check an unexpected payment notification by logging in and finding the transaction. PayPal says each transaction, including a pending one, appears in your transaction history. Source
Gumtree’s payments help says a PayPal confirmation email can be faked. Check that the money is in the account without using a link in the email. If the email says the payment will not appear for any reason, contact PayPal on its own website before you continue. Source
Gumtree’s PayPal scams guide says to open PayPal only in its app or at the real PayPal address, not from a link sent by a buyer or seller, and to check the account before sending the item. Be cautious if a buyer says they overpaid and you cannot see the payment. Source
Open the order independently
Close the message and open SilentSale® directly. Match the item and buyer to the paid order rather than following the email’s link.
Stripe processes payments and holds funds until the order completes.
If you already followed a link
Stop interacting with the page. Open your account directly and use Support to describe what happened. If you entered payment details, contact your payment provider through its own app or published contact details.
Keep a record for review
Retain the message, sender details and the time it arrived. Report the account or message through the app. Do not send more money to someone offering to recover the payment.
Use the Resolution Centre and in-app conversation to raise an issue, exchange evidence and try to agree a resolution before escalation for review.
Questions people ask
Is a fake PayPal email Gumtree buyers send proof I have been paid?
No. Gumtree says PayPal confirmation emails can be faked. Open PayPal yourself and check the account before you send the item.
What is a PayPal payment pending email scam?
It is an email that says a payment is pending or will appear later. PayPal says a pending transaction still shows in your transaction history after you log in.
What if the email uses a Wise logo?
Do not use the link. Open Wise yourself and check whether the money is there before you dispatch or meet.
Keep reading
Sources
- SilentSale® Terms and Conditions: payment, protection, acceptance and evidence rules. Checked 2026-10-02. §4.1–4.3, §6.5.1, §8.2–8.3
- PayPal official guidance, checked 2026-10-17. https://www.paypal.com/uk/cshelp/article/how-do-i-spot-a-fake-fraudulent-or-phishing-paypal-email-or-website---help164
- PayPal official guidance, checked 2026-10-17. https://www.paypal.com/uk/brc/article/what-is-phishing-or-spoofing
- Gumtree official guidance, checked 2026-10-17. https://www.gumtree.com/info/safety/p/payments/can-i-pay-for-items-on-gumtree/
- Gumtree official guidance, checked 2026-10-17. https://www.gumtree.com/info/safety/p/trust-safety/safety-advice-trust-safety/paypal-scams-on-gumtree/